How Insurance Companies Use Bias Against Motorcyclists

After a crash, many riders feel the insurance company has already decided who was at fault before the investigation begins. Bias against motorcyclists is rarely stated outright. It shows up in how adjusters frame questions, assign blame, and value injuries. Knowing these patterns helps you respond with evidence, not assumptions.
The Stereotype Behind the Tactics
Riders are often pictured as reckless, fast, and willing to take risks. Bias against motorcyclists can influence how an insurer reads a crash report, even when the facts point to a driver who failed to yield or turned across a rider’s path.
Insurers have a financial interest in paying less. A stereotype gives them a ready-made reason to argue that the rider, not the driver, should pay. Fault matters because California follows pure comparative negligence under Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804.
A rider may recover damages even when partly at fault, but the recovery is reduced by the rider’s share of fault. Every percentage point an insurer shifts to the rider lowers the claim.
Common Ways Bias Against Motorcyclists Shows Up
Riders commonly report these arguments after a crash:
- Blaming speed or lane position: The adjuster assumes the rider was going too fast or riding in the wrong place, even without evidence.
- Treating lane splitting as fault: The rider’s position between lanes becomes the headline, no matter how the driver behaved.
- Pointing to gear: Helmets, jackets, and boots become a focus even when they had nothing to do with causing the crash.
- Questioning the injuries: The insurer calls the injuries exaggerated, pre-existing, or unrelated to the crash.
- Making a quick, low offer: A fast settlement figure arrives before the rider knows the full extent of the harm.
- Asking for a recorded statement early: Questions about speed, distance, and what you saw can build a fault narrative.
None of these arguments is automatically valid. You can test each one against the evidence.

Why Small Shifts in Fault Matter
The dollars add up quickly. Suppose a jury found a rider 30 percent at fault for $100,000 in losses. The recovery would be reduced by 30 percent, to $70,000. This example is for illustration only and does not predict any result.
That is why bias against motorcyclists matters in practical terms. An insurer that moves even a modest share of fault onto the rider can reduce a claim without ever disproving the other driver’s negligence.
Lane Splitting Is Legal in California
Lane splitting is one of the most common points of attack. California Vehicle Code section 21658.1 took effect January 1, 2017. It defines lane splitting as driving a two-wheeled motorcycle between rows of stopped or moving vehicles in the same lane, and it allows the California Highway Patrol to develop educational guidelines.
The statute does not set a speed limit for lane splitting. The commonly cited 10 mph and 30 mph figures came from earlier CHP guidance, not from the law itself. Whether a rider acted reasonably depends on the circumstances.
Lane splitting alone does not prove fault, particularly when a driver changed lanes without signaling or checking mirrors. Our article on why lane splitting is legal in California explains the law in more detail.
Helmets, Gear, and Misplaced Blame
California requires riders and passengers to wear a DOT-compliant helmet under Vehicle Code section 27803. A rider who followed the law removes one argument from the insurer’s list.
When a helmet was not worn, an insurer may argue that it worsened a head injury. That argument generally relates only to injuries a helmet could have prevented. It does not usually reach unrelated injuries, such as fractures. Our article on California motorcycle helmet law explains how this works.
Minimizing Injuries and Low Offers
Motorcycle injuries can be severe because riders have little physical protection. They may include road rash, fractures, spinal injuries, and traumatic brain injuries. Even so, adjusters may call a crash “low impact” or argue that a rider’s pain comes from earlier conditions. This is another place where bias against motorcyclists can affect how an injury is valued.
Consistent medical care and clear records are a reliable response. Our overview of road rash injuries after a motorcycle accident shows why injuries that look minor can still carry real costs.
What California Requires of Insurers
Insurers must follow rules when they handle claims. Under California regulations, every insurer must conduct and diligently pursue a thorough, fair, and objective investigation. An investigation that starts with an assumption about riders does not meet that standard.
These rules are generally enforced through the California Department of Insurance. They do not replace the need for strong evidence in your own claim, but they do set expectations for how insurers should act.
How to Protect Your Claim
You can counter bias with facts. These steps help:
- Get medical care right away: Records link the crash to your injuries.
- Document the scene: Photograph vehicle positions, skid marks, lane markings, and signals. Ask the officer to note the other driver’s actions in the report.
- Collect witnesses: Neutral witnesses can describe how the other driver acted.
- Preserve video and gear: Keep helmet cameras, dashcam files, and your damaged helmet and clothing.
- Be careful with recorded statements: Speak with an attorney before answering an adjuster’s questions about speed or position.
- Avoid posting online: Photos and comments can be taken out of context, as we explain in our article on social media and personal injury claims.
- Do not rush a settlement: Wait until you understand the full extent of your injuries and future care.
California Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1 generally gives you two years from the date of injury to file a personal injury lawsuit.
Speak With a Los Angeles Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
Personal Injury Legal Group represents injured riders across Los Angeles and Southern California. We review how the crash happened, what evidence exists, and how an insurer assigns fault, so bias against motorcyclists doesn’t decide your claim, and it is judged on facts rather than assumptions.
To learn more, visit our Los Angeles motorcycle accident lawyer page. To discuss your situation, call 310-445-5900 or contact our team.
